From the Philippine Daily Inquirer (Dec 23): Law bans hit list of gov’t enemies
The military is now prohibited from issuing a hit list—officially called
“order of battle”—with the enactment of a law against enforced disappearances,
Malacañang said on Saturday. Order of battle is a list of people security forces say are “enemies of the
state” to make them “legitimate targets as combatants,” including those not
formally charged with crimes. People on the military’s hit list are open to assassinations, abductions,
harassment and intimidation.
Those who have disappeared are known as desaparecidos—the disappeared—a term
first used in Latin America to refer to the critics of the Chilean dictator
Augusto Pinochet who were seized by state security forces and never seen again.
Local security forces have used the order of battle to justify the seizure
and detention of critics of the government, mostly activists suspected of being
members of the communist New People’s Army or of front organizations belonging
to the communist movement in the Philippines. The new desaparecidos law “rejects [the] use of an order of battle or any
similar document to exempt” state agents from the prohibition or “justify” the
detention of enemies or critics of the government, President Aquino’s deputy
spokesperson, Abigail Valte, said in a radio interview.
The President signed the Anti-Enforced Disappearance Act late Friday, hours
after attending the 77th founding anniversary of the Armed Forces of the
Philippines (AFP). The new law, the first major human rights legislation under Mr. Aquino’s
nearly three-year-old administration, imposes up to life imprisonment for state
agents convicted of being involved in enforced disappearances. Its enactment has made the Philippines the first country in Asia to treat
enforced disappearance as an offense distinct from ordinary kidnapping.
US-based nongovernment organization Human Rights Watch challenged Mr. Aquino
to “move quickly to enforce it.” “Effective enforcement of this new law by the Philippine government will
deter enforced disappearances and address the deep-seated problem of impunity
for human-rights abusers,” Brad Adams, the group’s director for Asia, said in a
statement.
Missing
According to the human rights group Karapatan, more than 1,000 political
activists and suspected supporters have disappeared since the 1972-1986
dictatorship of Ferdinand Marcos, including more than 200 under Mr. Aquino’s
predecessor, Gloria Macapagal-Arroyo. Karapatan has documented 12 cases of enforced disappearance since 2010 under
Mr. Aquino.
The desaparecidos law defines an enforced disappearance as the abduction or
“any form of deprivation of liberty” of a person by state officials or their
agents who subsequently conceal the person’s fate or whereabouts. Human rights groups have reported that such people have been kept in a
network of “safe houses” where they are tortured and sometimes killed, their
bodies buried in unknown graves or dumped in remote areas. They say this was
extensively practiced during the Marcos regime. The law against enforced disappearance prohibits secret detention centers and
safe houses and authorizes the government to conduct “regular, unannounced …
inspections of all places of detention and confinement.” The law cannot be suspended even during wartime and does not permit amnesty
for those convicted. Superior officers of those found responsible are to be
equally penalized.
Reporting requirement
According to Valte, the law requires public officials and private citizens to
report forced disappearances, and state agencies to investigate cases and report
their findings. It also requires the regular updating of the lists of people being held in
state detention centers. The number of attacks against political opponents of the government has risen
alongside the growth of the 43-year-old communist insurgency and the
decades-long Moro rebellion in Mindanao, which appears close to a political
solution following a preliminary peace accord by the government and the Moro
Islamic Liberation Front signed in October.
Mr. Aquino, son of prodemocracy icons, has pledged to take steps to prosecute
violators of human rights during the previous administration and prevent new
ones. Rights groups, however, say violations have continued under his
administration. The groups have urged Mr. Aquino to prosecute violators of human rights
during the Arroyo administration, particularly retired Maj. Gen. Jovito
Palparan, who has gone into hiding after being ordered by a court to stand trial
for the enforced disappearance of University of the Philippines students Karen
Empeño and Sherlyn Cadapan in 2006. Palparan is also believed to have knowledge of the enforced disappearance of
left-leaning agriculturist Jonas Joseph Burgos, son of the late journalist Jose
Burgos, in 2007. Rights groups have also urged the Aquino administration to give priority to
the passage of a bill pending in Congress to compensate thousands of victims of
human rights abuses, including enforced disappearance, during the Marcos
dictatorship.
http://newsinfo.inquirer.net/328449/law-bans-hit-list-of-govt-enemies
Collecting order of battle information (weapons, equipment, personnel, etc.) on hostile insurgent organizations is a legtimate function of military intelligence. The Philippine military went a bridge too far by collecting data on civilian members of above ground, legal front organizations whose members may sympathize with insurgent ideology but have broken no Philippine laws. And in the past, some unscrupulous folks in the military used that OB data to illegally arrest/detain civilian front group members and on occasion some in the military even carried out the assassination of key front group cadre. While much of the military excess has been brought under control, the idea of the military compiling OB data on civilian noncombatants/citizens is still a concern. It will be interesting to see how the Philippine military responds to this legislation.
ReplyDelete